1980 Phillies = Tug K
1981 Dodgers = flyout to Ken Landreaux
1982 Cardinals = Sutter K
1983 Orioles = Maddox liner to Ripken
1984 Tigers = flyout to Larry Herndon
1985 Royals = flyout to Darryl Motley
1986 Mets = Orosco K
1987 Twins = grounder to Gary Gaetti
1988 Dodgers = Hershiser K
1989 Athletics = grounder to Tony Phillips
1990 Reds = foul pop to Todd Benzinger
1991 Twins = Gene Larkin walk-off single
1992 Blue Jays = bunt back to Timlin
1993 Blue Jays =

1994 xxxxxxxxxxxxxx
1995 Braves = flyout to Marquis Grissom
1996 Yankees = foul pop to Charlie Hayes
1997 Marlins = Renteria walk-off single
1998 Yankees = grounder to Scott Brosius
1999 Yankees = flyout to Chad Curtis
2000 Yankees = flyout to Bernie Williams
2001 Diamondbacks = Luis Gonzalez walk-off single
2002 Angels = flyout to Erstad
2003 Marlins = grounder back to Beckett
2004 Red Sox = grounder back to Foulke
2005 White Sox = grounder to Juan Uribe
2006 Cardinals = Wainwright K
2007 Red Sox = Papelbon K
2008 Phillies = Lidge K
2009 Yankees = Victorino grounder to Cano
2010 Giants = Wilson K
2011 Cardinals = flyout to Allen Craig
2012 Giants = Romo K
2013 Red Sox = Uehara K
2014 Giants = foul pop to Sandoval
2015 Royals = Wade Davis K
2016 Cubs = MiniMart grounder to Bryant
2017 Astros = grounder to Altuve
2018 Red Sox = Sale K
2019 Nationals = Hudson K