I went to the Army School of Advanced Military Studies (SAMS) in 2009-2010. 84 Army officers per year get to go to this elite institution. Hundreds if not thousands of Majors apply to attend this school. It is, without much hyperbole, where the intellectual elite of the Army (generally, there are some very smart officers in the Army believe it or not) get vectored towards by our mentors. It's difficult to just test in - a three part test including an essay, the test alone is over four hours long. You also have to get interviewed for a half an hour with one of the school faculty leadership after the test.
The writing standards are intense. Every paper, from the one to two page summaries to the 40-50 page monograph, are expected to be at the PhD level of writing, with proper footnoting and the like. It is completely original work, and for an example, my monograph was on an obscure topic that was critical for the generation of forces for overseas combat missions, and involved complexity science, queuing software, and an assload of research on senior leader (general officers and DoD civilian leadership) comments on this subject. Literally days of data mining to find a single quote within the proper context of the paper. Painful stuff.
But I was PROUD as fuck to have this paper written, approved and defended in front of a board of PhDs and full Colonels. It has been used by the Army to alter how they generate units for overseas deployment after it was published. It was critically examined on multiple occasions during the process, and there were a few revisions during the process.
Now, why does that matter? It matters because the War College is for Colonels. The school I went to was for Majors. The SAMS standards were unforgiving, we had multiple officers who failed papers, failed the oral comprehensive exam at the end of the course (five hours of hell), and were generally beaten around the head and shoulders for failure to meet the intellectual expectations of the course. And now we see the War College standards are shit - if this clown was able to graduate, how many other assholes were able to skate through with a combination of plagiarism and weak intellectual standards. And most troubling, Colonels become Generals, and if this is the intellectual expectation for our Colonels and Generals, there is no reason to wonder why we've been so unsuccessful in the last 13 years of conflict.
And my bosses wonder why I want to go to a civilian university fellowship for my War College instead of hanging out at Carlisle for a year chugging Yeungling and taken a year long highly paid sabbatical.
drsmooth wrote:Senator John Walsh (D-MT) gives new meaning to the expression "military intelligence"
Sorry General LG, but I mean ye gods