dajafi wrote:jerseyhoya wrote:From Social Security to Medicare to Medicare Part D all old people do is suck money from younger folks even though they're one of the wealthiest segments of the population because old people vote so damn much. It's lovely to see someone asking them to pay a little more for a change.
I have a lot of sympathy for this argument, especially as the actuarial tables have turned against us. (See what I did there?) The political nightmare is that while everybody knows that we'll have to raise the retirement age, possibly adjust/partially means-test SS or Medicare, and take serious steps toward squeezing out the (quite substantial) bloat and waste in the program, the AARP and related angry oldsters are so potent that this can only be done if both parties hold hands and jump together. Fat friggin' chance of that these days.
There's a substance argument against means-testing entitlement programs, summed up in the line "programs for the poor are invariably poor programs." IOW, the exact reason Social Security and Medicare work is that they reach wealthier beneficiaries. I'm starting to wonder if this is policy superstition, though.
And yet, out of the other side of the mouth, we're discouraged from having more than one yuppie pet per family...