dajafi wrote:The party not in the White House almost never has a clear, undisputed "leader."
I guess Newt Gingrich was that person for the Republicans between about 1994-98, but there was no one Republican at the beginning or end of the Clinton years until Bush won the 2000 nomination. If Al Gore had been a bit more intransigent after the disputed 2000 election, he probably could have been the Democrats' leader and presumptive nominee for '04, but he decided instead to binge-eat, grow a beard and make a movie. Other than Kerry for the months in '04 between when he was nominated and when he lost the general election, there was no one Democratic leader in the Bush years.
We could argue that this isn't really ideal, that it's yet another reflection of the Cult of the Presidency which I think most of us believe has been harmful. But it's the reality, and thus sort of a dumb argument as to whether the Republican "leader" is Rush, Beck, Steele, Joe the Plumber or John Boehner.
I don't think we have a leader at the moment, and agree trying to argue over which person is the leader of the party would be stupid because there is no answer. There are a number of people who are influential within the party. If I was to come up with a list of ten, off the top of my head I would say Rush, Beck, Steele, and Boehner from your list plus McConnell, Romney, Jindal, Pawlenty, McCain and Palin. Rush and Beck are more influential than McConnell or Boehner at getting people to show up angry at town hall meetings or march on the Capitol. McConnell, McCain and Boehner are sure as hell going to have more of a say though in what type of a stance the GOP caucuses take on the health care bill and on the Afghanistan debate, and those things matter a lot too. And the presidential contenders have a special place in the party leadership discussion because all of their internal ideological jockeying will become the most important down the line when one of them is picked as the nominee.
In closing, a party that had John McCain as its presidential nominee eleven months ago is not de facto led by Rush Limbaugh. Period.