There has been so much attention focused on the Yankees failing to get Cliff Lee last July and then again in the offseason that it is easy to forget that they dabbled with the idea of obtaining Dan Haren last July, as well, and offered some frustration that Houston never made them fully aware that Roy Oswalt was available. Perhaps the Yankees should have tried harder to obtain Haren and pushed harder to keep track of what was going on with Oswalt.
Haren pitched a one-hitter against the Indians on Tuesday night. That moved him to 8-4 since joining the Angels last July with a 2.43 ERA. In his 17 starts, he has failed to complete six innings just one time – his debut with the Angels last July 26. Meanwhile, since joining the Phillies, Oswalt is 9-1 with a 1.81 ERA, which is the best ERA in the majors (minimum 50 innings) in that timeframe. Oswalt has pitched fewer than six innings just once in 14 starts for Philadelphia.
The Yankees did not pursue Haren or Oswalt the way they might have because they believed that even after failing to obtain Lee in a trade, that they would simply sign the lefty in the offseason as a free agent. But, with hindsight, you could see how if the Yankees obtained either of those pitchers in July 2010, they would have been better constructed for the 2010 playoffs and the 2011 regular season ((both have contracts that covered them for 2011; Oswalt has an option for 2012, Haren for 2013). In fact, friends of Andy Pettitte had said that the lefty would have come back this year if the Yankees had been able to sign Lee. So maybe he would have felt the same way if the Yankees had Haren and, especially, Oswalt, who is a pal of Pettitte’s from their time together with the Astros.
If the Yankees have Pettitte in tandem with either Haren or Oswalt, right now, they would be viewed as the no-questions-asked AL East favorite. Especially since both would have cost considerably less in dollars than Lee (Oswalt makes $16 million this year, Haren $12.75 million), which would have given the Yankees plenty of maneuverability to either sign Rafael Soriano in the offseason or use the money in some other fashion.
NY Post